Constitutional Law
Nov. 16, 2026
Lawsuit challenges Newsom's plan to commute 548 death sentences
The lawsuit, filed by the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation on behalf of the coalition and victims' families, alleges Newsom exceeded his constitutional authority by pursuing widespread commutations without meaningful individualized reviews.
A coalition of California prosecutors, law enforcement officials and victims' rights advocates is challenging Gov. Gavin Newsom's plan to commute all 548 death sentences in the state, setting up a legal confrontation over the limits of executive clemency and the constitutional rights of crime victims.
The lawsuit, brought by the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation and other petitioners, contends Newsom exceeded his authority by pursuing blanket commutations without individualized reviews, adequate notice to prosecutors and victims, or compliance with statutory procedures. Friend v. Newsom, (Cal. Supreme Ct., filed Nov. 15, 2026).
But legal scholars and death penalty defense advocates argue the governor possesses broad constitutional authority to grant categorical clemency, pointing to historical precedent and a 2018 California Supreme Court decision emphasizing judicial deference to executive decisions.
Anne Marie Schubert, president and CEO of the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation and a former Sacramento County district attorney, said the lawsuit seeks to enforce constitutional limits on the governor's authority rather than challenge the death penalty as a matter of policy.
"This lawsuit is about the rule of law, constitutional limits on executive power, and victims' rights," Schubert said in an email Monday.
"The Governor has clemency authority, but he must follow the law. That includes providing legally required notice, respecting victims' rights, conducting meaningful individualized reviews, and obtaining the Supreme Court's recommendation where constitutionally required."
Schubert said her organization is working with district attorneys throughout California to examine the governor's list of intended commutation recipients and has already identified discrepancies in inmates' criminal histories.
"Even an accurate rap sheet may not provide the information necessary to determine the legal status of a prior conviction," she said.
She also maintained that providing notice after the governor announced his decision would not resolve the lawsuit's central objections.
"Our objection is to a blanket, predetermined outcome that circumvents these safeguards. Simply providing belated notice would not cure the fundamental problems with this process," Schubert said.
Greg Totten, CEO of the California District Attorneys Association and a former Ventura County district attorney, characterized the governor's action as a fundamental misuse of executive power.
"We believe this is a very serious abuse of power by the governor, who has essentially unilaterally substituted his personal views on the death penalty for thousands of jurors who sat on these cases, hundreds of judges who affirmed these convictions, and the electorate themselves," Totten said in a phone call Monday.
He argued that clemency inherently requires examining individual circumstances, including the underlying crime, an inmate's conduct and potential grounds for mercy.
"None of that was done in this case," Totten said. "It was just a blanket en masse kind of decision."
Santa Barbara criminal defense attorney Robert Sanger, who said he was preparing an amicus brief on behalf of California Attorneys for Criminal Justice, rejected the lawsuit's premise and characterized the separate legal challenge as an unnecessary attempt to circumvent the Supreme Court's existing review process.
"This is a publicity seeking end run on the procedure put into effect by the Supreme Court," Sanger said in an email Monday.
He argued that the petitioners should participate in the pending proceeding concerning Newsom's request for Supreme Court approval rather than pursue a separate writ petition.
"They are filing a separate action rather than simply responding to the invitation to file an amicus brief in the actual pending matter," Sanger said. "It seems to be grandstanding and I suspect that the Court will disregard it and proceed with the above matter as ordered."
Sanger also disputed the contention that the governor must evaluate each prisoner's individual circumstances before granting clemency.
"There is no provision or requirement for individualized consideration," Sanger said. "The Supreme Court has previously rejected that approach."
He maintained that statutory procedures governing applications submitted through the Board of Parole Hearings do not restrict the governor when he initiates clemency himself.
"The Legislature cannot place requirements on the constitutional authority of the Governor in any event," Sanger said.
The governor announced Nov. 5 that he intended to replace every death sentence with life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. The commutations would not release prisoners, overturn convictions or eliminate restitution obligations.
Under Article V, Section 8 of the California Constitution, commutations for individuals twice convicted of felonies require recommendations from at least four California Supreme Court justices.
Newsom has sought the court's approval for 382 condemned prisoners falling within that category.
Kern County District Attorney Cynthia Zimmer, a petitioner in the lawsuit, raised additional concerns about the accuracy of the governor's classifications, saying her office identified potential problems involving three of six inmates whose cases were not submitted for Supreme Court review
"Ensuring the accuracy of these records requires substantial time and diligent investigation," Zimmer said in an email Monday.
San Bernardino County District Attorney Jason Anderson, another petitioner, raised concerns about the classification of condemned inmate Floyd Smith, whose prior murder conviction the California Supreme Court accepted as a valid basis for a special circumstance finding. Anderson said that determination supported treating Smith as a twice-convicted felon requiring Supreme Court review.
"Smith's classification as a twice-convicted felon rests upon this adjudication and review. Our office has no reason to doubt the Supreme Court on that issue," Anderson said in a statement.
Anderson also questioned whether the governor had adequately examined inmates' conduct while incarcerated, including whether any had committed assaults or more serious offenses since receiving their death sentences.
"This is why an individualized review of each case is necessary," Anderson said.
"The Governor should not move forward with hundreds of commutations until the records are verified, the law is followed, and, most importantly, victims are given the meaningful opportunity to be heard that the California Constitution requires."
Sacramento County District Attorney Thien Ho, also a petitioner in the lawsuit, said the challenge concerns whether hundreds of death sentences can be altered without meaningful scrutiny of individual cases and victims' interests.
"Justice requires case-by-case consideration, not one-size-fits-all decisions," Ho said in a statement Monday.
He argued that each death sentence reflects years of proceedings involving juries, judges and multiple layers of appellate review, and that blanket commutations disregard those determinations.
Ho also pointed to California voters' rejection of two ballot measures to abolish capital punishment and their approval of Proposition 66 in 2016, which sought to expedite death penalty appeals and other procedures.
"This challenge is about ensuring that decisions affecting hundreds of cases, countless victims' families, and some of California's most notorious murderers receive meaningful scrutiny rather than being resolved through a single blanket action," Ho said.
However, UC Berkeley law professor Ty Alper disputed the lawsuit's premise.
"Under the California Constitution, the Governor has broad power to grant clemency," Alper said in an email Monday. "This includes the power to grant clemency to everyone sentenced to death based on his concerns with the sentence of death."
Alper also disputed allegations that Newsom failed to provide required notice, saying the governor had sent individualized letters to victims and district attorneys, invited them to webinars and made telephone calls to victims for whom contact information was available. He emphasized that no sentences had yet been commuted.
UC Berkeley School of Law Dean Erwin Chemerinsky similarly said California law does not require individualized determinations or the statutory application procedures cited by opponents when the governor acts on his own initiative.
He pointed to governors in Illinois, Oregon and New Mexico who previously commuted entire death rows.
Attorney Robert D. Bacon, who submitted an amicus letter on behalf of 19 academics supporting Newsom's proposed commutations, argued that the governor's constitutional authority permits categorical clemency without individualized consideration.
In a 2018 administrative order, the California Supreme Court explained that its role is not to decide whether an applicant deserves mercy but whether the proposed clemency would constitute an abuse of executive power.
Appellate attorney David S. Ettinger said the court could meaningfully review hundreds of commutations together by examining Newsom's stated justification that capital punishment is unjust and immoral.
Ettinger also suggested the justices might temporarily block commutations not requiring their approval while considering the petition.
Sanger, however, maintained that the separate writ proceeding is unnecessary because the Supreme Court has already established a process for receiving arguments on the governor's request.
"The sole issue is whether under the specific provision of Article V, section 8, there is a legitimate basis for the Governor to commute the sentences of the twice convicted," Sanger said.
Newsom, responding through his office, pointed to his Nov. 5 public letter acknowledging the suffering of victims' families while defending the decision as an exercise of constitutional authority.
"But the constitution also gave every governor clemency authority, and that power exists for moments when law as applied cannot be squared with justice," Newsom wrote. "For me, this is that moment."
Skyler Romero
skyler_romero@dailyjournal.com
For reprint rights or to order a copy of your photo:
Email
Jeremy_Ellis@dailyjournal.com
for prices.
Direct dial: 213-229-5424
Send a letter to the editor:
Email: letters@dailyjournal.com