Over nearly three decades as a JAMS neutral, Cathy A. Yanni has handled some of the nation's most complex mass torts, multidistrict litigations, and class actions. But she maintains that the most important skill in resolving disputes is not legal expertise. It's building relationships.
"The key to being successful in my business is understanding and respecting all the different people involved," Yanni said. "And to be flexible in your views on things so you can really listen. That listening factor is key, and it doesn't matter if you're a trustee, a special master or in a single mediation."
That approach has guided Yanni through some of the largest and most emotionally charged settlement proceedings in recent years, including her work as trustee of the Fire Victim Trust, which has distributed $14.2 billion to more than 70,000 claimants affected by the 2015 Butte, 2017 North Bay and 2018 Camp fires.
In 2025, Yanni was appointed special master for the Maui Fires Individual Settlement Fund, which involves approximately $3.5 billion in payments to more than 20,000 victims of the August 2023 Lahaina wildfire. She has also helped resolve complex disputes arising from devastating wildfires in Colorado and Oregon.
The work has reinforced her belief that even the largest settlement programs ultimately come down to individual lives.
"It's just shocking what many, many fire victims have gone through," Yanni said, referring to people who lost loved ones, homes and businesses. "Your life changes in a matter of 24 hours. ... And being aware of that is very important for anybody working on these cases."
As her responsibilities with the Fire Victims Trust wind down, Yanni is looking forward to taking on more mediations. She said she considers preparation essential, particularly in complex disputes involving numerous parties and competing interests. Before a mediation, she typically conducts conferences with counsel to better understand the participants, the issues dividing them and what each side hopes to accomplish.
Equally important, she said, is creating an environment in which parties feel comfortable discussing their concerns.
"Each mediation - no matter what kind of case it is - is very, very personal to everybody there," said Yanni, who spent 14 years litigating personal injury, insurance, and employment disputes before becoming a full-time neutral in the late 1990s.
"And you have to keep in mind that this is their day to make their case in front of somebody who's neutral," she continued. "So, I want to try to understand and to help people feel comfortable with actually digging into what the issues are and resolving them."
San Francisco plaintiffs' attorney Elizabeth J. Cabraser has worked with Yanni on many complex matters, including a high-profile opioid multidistrict litigation in which Cabraser represented Native American tribes.
Cabraser recalled that Yanni devoted considerable time to understanding the tribes' cultures, governance and concerns, traveling to tribal lands and meeting with tribal leaders.
"To me, that is just quintessentially what Cathy Yanni does as a mediator," Cabraser said. "She sees herself as a problem-solver. But before she can address the problem and solve the problem, she has to understand it from the point of view of all the actors."
San Francisco defense attorney Michael F. Healy, who has worked with Yanni on pharmaceutical and medical device disputes over the past decade, praised her command of the law and ability to evaluate complicated evidence.
"She's an expert on the law," Healy said. "So, there's no education required."
That expertise, he explained, is particularly valuable when representing corporations whose in-house counsel expect a neutral to understand the legal standards and expert testimony underlying their cases.
Healy said Yanni's credibility extends across both sides of the bar, giving parties confidence that their positions will receive a fair hearing.
"She's got just as strong a reputation with the defense bars as she does with the plaintiffs' bars," he said.
That reputation also makes her a frequent choice for attorneys who have worked with her before.
"I also like to refer to her as a closer," Healy said. "Meaning the cases that should settle - she gets them settled."
San Francisco plaintiffs' attorney Steven J. Skikos, who has worked with Yanni on the Fire Victims Trust and pharmaceutical litigation, offered a similar assessment.
"I've worked with her for a quarter of a century," Skikos said. "And in every single case in which we've worked, it ended up with a successful resolution."
He said Yanni's effectiveness stems partly from her ability to build trust with opposing counsel and accurately assess what each side can deliver.
"Whether it's plaintiff or defense, she knows how to get cases settled," Skikos said. "The real key for mediation is when somebody says, 'I think I can deliver this,' they have to be able to deliver it, and she can do that."
Cabraser, who also worked with Yanni during her tenure as trustee of the Fire Victims Trust, emphasized a different quality: what she described as the neutral's "almost unlimited capacity for empathy."
For lawyers representing people who have suffered devastating losses, Cabraser said, having someone genuinely listen to their clients can be as important as understanding the legal issues.
"The thing we all want as lawyers more than anything in the world is for somebody to pay attention to what our clients have to say," Cabraser explained.
"We just want somebody to see, to hear, to understand a problem from the perspective of our client and then help us help our clients come to a solution that also addresses the legitimate interests and concerns of the other side. And Cathy can do that. Not everybody can."
Skikos said Yanni's combination of legal knowledge, practical experience and interpersonal skills makes her particularly effective in sprawling disputes that require more than conventional settlement negotiations.
"If you have a strategically complex case that requires somebody who understands discovery, understands the federal courts, understands relationships and conflicts, can comprehend the law - put all that together and that's why she gets appointed by courts," he said. "She can handle the full gamut of issues that relate to mediation."
For Yanni, the transition back toward more individual mediations represents an opportunity to apply the same approach that has guided her work administering multibillion-dollar settlements.
Whether she is overseeing thousands of claims or helping two parties resolve a single dispute, she said, the objective remains understanding the people involved and finding a workable resolution.
And after nearly three decades as a neutral, she has no intention of slowing down.
"I love what I do," Yanni said. "And this is the way I look at it: I help people every single day, and that's pretty amazing."
Here are some attorneys who have used Yanni's services: Elizabeth J. Cabraser, Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein LLP, Michael F. Healy, Shook Hardy & Bacon LLP; Steven J. Skikos, Skikos Crawford Skikos & Joseph LLP; Todd M. Logan, Edelson PC; Frank M. Pitre, Cotchett Pitre & McCarthy LLP