| Case # | Name | Category | Court | Judge | Published | 
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 
 G055631 
 | 
Placencia v. Strazicich 
 Probate court did not err by denying petitioner's right of survivorship to joint bank account because decedent left clear statements in his will that he did not want petitioner to have the right of survivorship.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
R. Ikola | Dec. 2, 2019 | 
| 
 G056234 
 | 
MTC Financial Inc. v. California Dept. of Tax and Fee Admin.
 A trust deed must sufficiently describe the property securing it to be enforceable. A parcel number, address, and trustor names are insufficient to describe trust property to avoid voidability.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
E. Moore | Nov. 1, 2019 | 
| 
 C084020 
 | 
Hodges v. County of Placer 
 California counties do not owe a fiduciary duty to property owners while holding the owner's property in a trust account after a tax sale.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
H. Hull | Oct. 30, 2019 | 
| 
 G056353 
 | 
Levin v. Winston-Levin 
 In order to be liable for double damages under Probate Code Section 859, it must be proven that the accused person acted in bad faith.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
R. Ikola | Sep. 16, 2019 | 
| 
 C083266 
 | 
Pena v. Dey
 Because trust's amendment provision requires an amendment be 'signed by the settlor,' the settlor's interlineations without his signature did not effectively amend the trust.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
A. Hoch | Sep. 4, 2019 | 
| 
 B288074 
 | 
Blech v. Blech 
 Creditor may file Probate Code Section 15301(b) petition to enforce a money judgment against a nondiscretionary principal distribution before that distribution is due and payable.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
L. Lavin | Aug. 20, 2019 | 
| 
 B284521 
 | 
Gonzalez v. City National Bank 
 42 U.S.C. Section 1396p(d)(4)(A) mandates that Department of Health Care Services seek recovery of total medical assistance paid on behalf of beneficiary in special needs trust containing that condition.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
N. Stone | Jun. 26, 2019 | 
| 
 E068030 
 | 
Estate of Sapp 
 Administrator of decedent's estate was 'otherwise not qualified' under Probate Code Section 8502(b) and acted in bad faith toward heirs; thus, probate court properly removed her as administrator.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
A. McKinster | Jun. 12, 2019 | 
| 
 B268380 
 | 
Han v. Hallberg 
 Trust is a 'person' that may associate in a partnership under Uniform Partnership Act; thus, buyout provisions under dentists' partnership agreement not triggered because trust was partner and not dentist, as individual.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
E. Grimes | May 23, 2019 | 
| 
 G054989 
 | 
Stennett v. Miller
 Nonmarital biological child of absentee father who never openly held her out as his own does not have standing to assert cause of action for his wrongful death.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
R. Aronson | Apr. 16, 2019 | 
| 
 D073491 
 | 
Dudek v. Dudek 
 Once a donative transfer is executed by the owner of a life insurance policy, the transferee owns the policy; thus, the trial court erred in finding that a trust did not exist.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
C. Aaron | Apr. 11, 2019 | 
| 
 E068698 
 | 
Estate of Herzog 
 Code of Civil Procedure Section 1930 states that in order for the mark on a document to be an official 'seal,' it must include a signature by a public official.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
D. Miller | Apr. 2, 2019 | 
| 
 H044213 
 | 
Trolan v. Trolan 
 A court cannot substitute its judgment and discretion for that of a trustees' if the trustees are acting within proper limits, unless there is a complete failure or refusal to perform the duties of the trustees.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
M. Greenwood | Feb. 1, 2019 | 
| 
 G056105 
 | 
Conservatorship of Ribal 
 Probate Code Section 859 limits liability to double damages, and any other remedies available in law, for people taking or disposing of property in a manner that constitutes financial elder abuse.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
E. Moore | Jan. 22, 2019 | 
| 
  B281758 
 | 
Smith v. Szeyller
 Probate court had discretion to order attorney fees and expert fees from trust assets under the substantial benefit doctrine because record supported the finding that the litigation substantially benefited all beneficiaries.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
S. Perren | Jan. 17, 2019 | 
| 
 A152538 
 | 
Modification: Estate of Stockird
 Statutory interpretation of the definition of a 'transferee' under the probate code, for purposes of a failed distribution, is not limited to blood relatives.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
S. Margulies | Jan. 14, 2019 | 
| 
 A152538 
 | 
Estate of Stockird
 Statutory interpretation of the definition of a 'transferee' under the probate code, for purposes of a failed distribution, is not limited to blood relatives.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
S. Margulies | Dec. 24, 2018 | 
| 
 A151070 
 | 
Schwan v. Permann 
 Probate court properly relied on the doctrine of impossibility; although Probate Code Section 142 was repealed, the doctrine of impossibility was left to case law development.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
S. Margulies | Oct. 29, 2018 | 
| 
 G055189 
 | 
Orange Catholic Foundation v. Arvizu 
 Under Restatement Second of Trusts Section 205, the good faith exception imbues a court with the power to excuse a trustee from liability where he has acted honestly and reasonably.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
E. Moore | Oct. 19, 2018 | 
| 
 F076395 
 | 
Barefoot v. Jennings 
 Where former beneficiary is 'expressly disinherited' from inter vivos trust by amendment, that party lacks standing to challenge reserved for beneficiaries.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
B. Hill | Sep. 11, 2018 | 
| 
 D072566 
 | 
Modification: Powell v. Tagami
 Sufficient evidence supports court finding that trust beneficiary objected to accounting in bad faith where beneficiary fails to show reasonable cause supported objection.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
J. McConnell | Sep. 6, 2018 | 
| 
 D072566 
 | 
Modification: Powell v. Tagami
 Sufficient evidence supports court finding that trust beneficiary objected to accounting in bad faith where beneficiary fails to show reasonable cause supported objection.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
J. McConnell | Sep. 5, 2018 | 
| 
 D071284  
 | 
Estate of O'Connor
 A donee's exercise of a power of appointment must contain enough detail that it reasonable to conclude he or she made an intentional and deliberate, not inadvertent, exercise of that power.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
T. O'Rourke | Aug. 31, 2018 | 
| 
 E062672 
 | 
Scott v. McDonald 
 Where probate court explicitly sets out proper legal standards as basis for its decisions, appellant's challenge that court applied in correct standards fails.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
D. Miller | Aug. 24, 2018 | 
| 
 E066177 
 | 
Conservatorship of Presha 
 Although Probate Code Section 2620(d) applies to accountings and not to petitions for conservator's fees the probate court's error was harmless because it has the authority to examine billing practices.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
D. Miller | Aug. 24, 2018 | 
| 
 A152351 
 | 
Cortese v. Sherwood 
 A cause of action can still fall within the initial scope of Civil Code Section 1714.10 without regard to whether the word 'conspiracy' appears in the cause of action.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
B. Jones | Aug. 23, 2018 | 
| 
 D072566 
 | 
Powell v. Tagami 
 Sufficient evidence supports court finding that trust beneficiary objected to accounting in bad faith where beneficiary fails to show reasonable cause supported objection.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
J. McConnell | Aug. 17, 2018 | 
| 
 B268326 
 | 
Blech v. Blech 
 Probate court erred by deeming gift a specific gift instead of a residuary gift, but overall treatment in settling estate was proper.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
A. Goodman | Aug. 8, 2018 | 
| 
 16-16155 
 | 
Amended Opinion: Glazing Health & Welfare Fund v. Lamek
 Unpaid contributions to employee benefit funds are not plan assets; employers contractually committed to make such payments are not fiduciaries under ERISA.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
M. Friedland | Jul. 20, 2018 | 
| 
 A151975 
 | 
Estate of Post 
 Probate court has limited jurisdiction, over res of decedent's estate; does not have jurisdiction over decedent's choice of beneficiary to insurance policy.  | 
probate_and_trusts | 
 | 
R. Dondero | Jun. 28, 2018 | 
